Many in the voluntary carbon offset space are aware of recent debates surrounding the ‘tokenization’ of carbon credits. To ‘tokenize’ is to create a digital representation of a particular asset or piece of data in a format which can be usable on a blockchain platform. A token typically consists of a unique code with digital registration of origin which enables secure acquisition and validation of some kind of property, in this case a registered carbon offset credit.1
Tokenizing carbon credits has both potential benefits and drawbacks. The past year has seen a great deal of development in the tokenized offset credit space, and at least a couple of significantly disruptive events. Many entities in the voluntary offset space are justifiably concerned with maintaining integrity and trust in the market, and they see tokenization as a risky proposition that must be done securely and cautiously. The two largest offset accreditation registries, Gold Standard and Verra, are currently trying to create frameworks for the process that enable the good aspects and avoid the bad ones.
At face value, the tokenization of carbon credits could offer solutions to some of the voluntary offset markets most intractable problems. For example, opacity in transaction and price data has long been one of the market’s key challenges in terms of creating liquidity and scaling its impact, and navigating this has been one of cCarbon’s prime objectives in our coverage of the VCM. Because tokenized credits can be exchanged on a public platform without the barriers to entry and opacity of current commodity exchanges or over-the-counter agreements, price transparency could potentially be achieved on a public blockchain-based exchange. A public platform could also open the market to a wider range of participants, and therefore finance.
Another potential benefit of tokenization is that it can help to address double-counting. Because of the lack of transparent transaction data, and the fragmentation of accreditation across registries, there is currently no meta-layer by which to easily check whether credits are being counted twice. The recently developed World Bank Climate Warehouse’s Climate Action Data Trust has already begun crafting such an infrastructure, built on blockchain, and aims to launch it this December. Credits traded on this kind of public platform, one which is inclusive of all registries, could lead to more efficient and comprehensive credit tracking.
Another way that tokenized credits could bring additional liquidity to the voluntary market is through pooling. Because of the multiplicity of registries and their respective accreditation methodologies, voluntary offset credits are split across a wide spectrum of categories. When a credit is tokenized, it retains the unique characteristics of the project it came from. However, once it is bridged to a blockchain platform, it can also be easily sorted by any combination of these characteristics. For example, one could create a specific pool that allowed only vintage 2020 biochar removal credits.
With a pool of such similar credits, supply volumes could achieve greater stability, and pricing credits could become more transparent and consistent. The idea of pooling has generated positive responses from several important entities in the VCM space such as Verra and IETA.2
Although there are some compelling reasons to tokenize offset credits, there are also several reasons that registries are approaching the technology with caution. The most straightforward of these is the desire to maintain the intended environmental impact of carbon offset credits. Today there are many different blockchain platforms, some of which use a great deal of energy, and are thus carbon intensive. Depending on the platform, it is very possible that a token could be exchanged so many times that the energy intensity could outweigh the original carbon offset itself. However, as many blockchain platforms have recently looked to minimize their energy intensity, and some are even going carbon negative, this drawback can be avoided by choosing the appropriate platform.
Another problem that has been pointed out by several registries is the potential for using carbon credits as a means of money laundering or funding illegal operations. All four major registries are already committed to know-your-customer (KYC) checks either upon account registration or credit generation. Because blockchain transactions occur fluidly across national boundaries, and by their nature are difficult to restrict, there has been a great deal of emphasis put on the need for KYC checks. There is ongoing debate amongst several registries, as well as IETA’s Task Force on Integrity In Digital Climate Markets, as to what degree transaction-level KYC checks are necessary for tokenized credits, as well as whether KYC checks are necessary at retirement in general.3 Just days ago, the blockchain-based carbon offset ‘bridge’ platform Toucan Protocol announced that they would update their framework to require KYC checks for any entities ‘bridging’ carbon credits from their physical registration to a digital token. This is likely in direct preparation for the requirements currently being discussed by registries such as Verra and Gold Standard.
The last issue which I will address here, and for many the most important, is the question of integrity. While blockchain can be a vehicle for transparency, it is not necessarily so, and the structures for ensuring transparency must be robust and carefully crafted. Perhaps just as importantly, the registries have already seen the potential negative impact of bringing credits ‘on-chain’. The story of tokenized credit exchange Klima DAO may by now be familiar to many, but I will summarize it briefly here. Before Verra and other registries prohibited tokenization in May of this year, Toucan Protocol had already bridged over 22 million credits. As these tokens proceeded to be traded on the Klima DAO exchange, it was discovered that the composition of this credit pool was unusual, and in fact consisted of many credits which, before their tokenization, had been abandoned by the market. As much as 28% of the Toucan-bridged credits came from projects which either “hadn’t recorded a single public retirement for two years prior to bridging, or 2) had made over 95% of their publicly recorded credit retirements through Toucan”.4 Of course, this caused great alarm among many in the VCM space including Verra, the standard from which many of these credits had come, and tokenization was quickly put on hold.
In the past several months the four major voluntary offset registries have begun re-organizing their approach to tokenized offset credits. The current Verra and Gold Standard consultations are a direct reaction to this series of events, and the registries are seeking to ensure that if tokenization proceeds, as many expect it to, it will be done in a way that avoids potential problems.
Currently only Gold Standard and ACR allow any form of tokenization of their credits, and this is strictly limited to those with explicit permission from the registry. Verra and CAR currently prohibit any tokenization, and, according to their recent public comment event, Verra does not expect this to change until 2023 at least. Verra’s caution in adopting a tokenization policy has caused some to wonder if their long-standing position as the dominant registry could be disrupted by the technology.

Verra represents a large majority of current offset credits. Could tokenization disrupt their long-standing dominance?
Progression towards tokenized carbon credits, however, has not been completely halted by the major registries decision-making processes, and many smaller entities are proceeding to leverage blockchain technology. Some of these actors are proceeding directly with tokenization of other types of credits and offset projects, and some are pioneering new uses for the technology in the decarbonization space. This article will be followed by another which will seek to describe some of these smaller actors, and some of the other novel ways that blockchain technology has started to merge with carbon markets and carbon offset projects.
Analyst Contact: Gabe Stoltzfus (gstoltzfus@ckinetics.com)
Our market portals and InSights are only for logged-in users with the relevant access. This can be you too…
Your Current Membership Does not Include this Content
This content is outside of your current package. If you need this too, let’s talk…
Send this problem to our Clients team, and we will get back to you shortly with a plan of attack.
Speak and exchange notes with our specific-market expert, use your complimentary hours.
Arrange with Client TeamTell us who you are, and what you're after. We'll find you the right person with the answer - before you wake up twice.
Tell us who you are, and what you're after. We'll find you the right person with the answer - before you wake up twice.
Your Current Membership Does not Include this Content
This content is outside of your current package.
If you need this too, let's talk…
Phasellus tempor tincidunt sem, sed dictum ipsum mollis vitae. Maecenas eu diam convallis, pellentesque lacus et, mollis enim.
| ID # | Custom Name | Created On | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
Phasellus tempor tincidunt sem, sed dictum ipsum mollis vitae. Maecenas eu diam convallis, pellentesque lacus et, mollis enim.
| # ID | Custom Name | Created On | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|